
Deferred CompensationAn arrangement where a portion of your income is set aside today and paid out at a future date — typically retirement — when you may be in a lower tax bracket. Non-qualified deferred compensation plans are common among executives, but they carry real risk: if the company goes bankrupt, you’re an unsecured creditor for those funds. Planner
Is Deferring Compensation Worth It After Tax?
It can be when your tax rate in the payout years is lower than today’s, but deferred pay is an unsecured promise from your employer and payout elections are hard to change. This calculator compares deferring into a 409A or 457 plan with taking the pay now, after 2026 tax, and shows which state can tax the payouts.
What Does the Deferred Compensation Calculator Estimate?
Nonqualified deferred compensation is pay you earn now but receive later, often in retirement. Many companies let higher-paid employees defer salary or bonus into a nonqualified deferred compensation plan governed by Internal Revenue Code section 409A. Tax-exempt employers such as hospitals and universities may offer a 457(b) plan, with a yearly limit of $24,500 in 2026 (IRS Notice 2025-67), or a 457(f) plan, taxed when it vests. Deferring can help when your tax rate in the payout years is lower than it is today, but the deferred amount is an unsecured promise from your employer, and payout elections are hard to change.
This calculator compares the after-tax payouts from deferring with taking the pay now and investing it in a taxable account sold on the same schedule. It shows the tax rate on the payouts, the break-even rate at which the two come out the same, the Social Security and Medicare tax due this year, whether your current work state could still tax payouts after you move, how much the company would owe you and for how long, and what a Section 409A failure would cost. It is an educational estimate, not tax, legal, or investment advice.
How Is Deferring Compared With Taking the Pay Now?
What it estimates: the after-tax value of deferring compared with taking the pay now, the tax on each payout year, the break-even tax rate, which state can tax the payouts, Social Security and Medicare tax, how much is owed to you and until when, and the 20% additional tax if a plan failed Section 409A (section 409A(a)(1)(B)).
What you enter: This Year’s Decision: Amount You Could Defer, Type of Plan (elective deferral, excess benefit only, a tax-exempt employer’s 457(b), or 457(f)), the 457(b) special catch-up where it applies, Other Income This Year, Filing Status, State Where You Work Now, and Local Income Tax (shown when that state has one: a Maryland county or Baltimore City, a city, county or school district in Alabama, Colorado, Delaware, Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Michigan, Missouri, New York, Ohio, Oregon or Pennsylvania, or a rate you enter). Your Payout: Years Until Payouts Start, Payout Form (lump sum, annual installments, or annual payments for life) and its length, Other Income Each Payout Year, State Where You Expect to Live at Payout, and an optional Assumed Yearly Growth. Changing a Payout Later (Optional): What Starts the Payment, whether you are a key employee of a public company, the date you expect to leave, the first scheduled payment date, and the date you would make the change. The calculator opens in Quick estimate mode with the amount, plan type, income, filing status, states, years until payout, and growth; Detailed mode shows every field.
1. Taking it now
The 2026 federal, state, and local income tax and the Social Security and Medicare tax on the pay this year. What is left is invested in a taxable account.
2. Deferring
The deferred amount grows at the rate you enter, if any, until payouts start. A 457(b) deferral above the yearly limit is cut to the limit.
3. The payouts
Each payout year, the payment is the balance divided by the payments left, taxed on top of the payout-year income you enter, in the state where you expect to live.
4. The comparison
The after-tax payouts compared with the taxable account sold on the same schedule, each sale’s gain taxed as a long-term gain.
5. Your former work state
Federal law (4 U.S.C. 114) stops a former work state from taxing payments for life, yearly payments over 10 or more years, and excess benefit plan payments. Other forms may still be taxed there, so the result is shown as a range.
6. Social Security and Medicare
Under the special timing rule, these taxes are due when the pay is earned and vested, not when it is paid.
7. If the employer cannot pay
The amount the company owes you when payouts start and the years until the last payment, as an unsecured promise.
8. Changing a payout (optional)
The last day to change a scheduled payment and the earliest new date under the 12-month and 5-year rules, and the 6-month wait for a key employee of a public company (Internal Revenue Code section 409A).
What you see: Deferring Compared With Taking It Now first, then the After-Tax Payouts If You Defer, the After-Tax Amount If You Take It Now, Tax on This Pay If Taken Now, the Plan Balance When Payouts Start, the Tax Rate and Break-Even Tax Rate on the Payouts, whether payouts are exempt from your former work state’s tax, Social Security and Medicare, the amount owed, and the cost of a Section 409A failure. Tables show the payout schedule year by year and a lump sum compared with installments of different lengths.
What Assumptions and Sources Does It Use?
- Tax year: 2026 for the deferral year. Payout years use 2026 federal brackets and the payout-year income you enter, not adjusted for inflation.
- Section 409A: deferred pay is taxed when paid if the plan follows section 409A. A change to a payout must wait 12 months to take effect, move the payment at least 5 years later, and, for a fixed-date payment, be made at least 12 months before that date (section 409A(a)(4)(C)). A key employee of a public company paid because of leaving waits at least 6 months (section 409A(a)(2)(B)(i)). A plan that fails section 409A makes vested amounts taxable at once, with a 20% additional tax and premium interest (section 409A(a)(1)(B)).
- 457 plans: a tax-exempt employer’s 457(b) plan is limited to $24,500 of deferrals in 2026 (section 457(e)(15); IRS Notice 2025-67), with a special catch-up in the 3 years before the plan’s normal retirement age (section 457(b)(3)). A 457(f) plan is taxed when it vests (section 457(f)(1)(A)). A government’s 457(b) plan is not modeled here.
- Social Security and Medicare: 6.2% Social Security up to $184,500 of wages and 1.45% Medicare, plus 0.9% above the Additional Medicare Tax threshold (IRS Topic 751, 2026), due when the pay is earned and vested (section 3121(v)(2)).
- State tax on payouts: 4 U.S.C. 114 bars a former work state from taxing a nonresident’s payments for life, yearly payments over at least 10 years, and excess benefit plan payments. Other payouts may be taxed by the state where the pay was earned, and any credit from your home state is shown as Unknown.
- Taking it now: the after-tax pay is invested in a taxable account and sold on the plan’s payout schedule, each sale’s gain taxed as a long-term gain. Growth is a rate you choose for both, or none.
- Not modeled: your plan’s own rules, employer credits, early or emergency payouts, payment at death, and estate taxA federal (and sometimes state) tax on the transfer of assets to heirs at death, assessed on the total estate value above the applicable exemption. The federal exemption is $15 million per person in 2026: the 2025 law known as the One Big Beautiful Bill Act set it at that level, indexed for inflation after 2026, with no scheduled sunset..
Worked Example
The example
This is the calculator’s built-in Detailed example (the “Reset to example” values). Every figure below is the calculator’s own output for these inputs. It is hypothetical and uses 2026 rules. Payout years are counted from the year the calculator is used; this example was run on November 2, 2026.
Inputs
| Input | Example value |
|---|---|
| Amount You Could Defer | $100,000 |
| Type of Plan | Elective Deferral Plan |
| Other Income This Year | $400,000 |
| Filing Status | Married Filing Jointly |
| State Where You Work Now | Maryland |
| Local Income Tax | Typical Maryland rate (3.20%) |
| Years Until Payouts Start | 10 |
| Payout Form | Annual Installments |
| Number of Annual Installments | 5 |
| Other Income Each Payout Year | $120,000 |
| State Where You Expect to Live at Payout | Florida |
| Assumed Yearly Growth | Not entered (no growth) |
| What Starts the Payment | A Fixed Date or Schedule |
Results
| Result | Estimate |
|---|---|
| Deferring Compared With Taking It Now | +$17,840 to +$22,590 |
| After-Tax Payouts If You Defer | $84,500 |
| After-Tax Amount If You Take It Now | $61,910 |
| Tax on This Pay If Taken Now | $38,090 |
| If Your Payout Income and State Matched Today’s | +$5,140 |
| Plan Balance When Payouts Start | $100,000 |
| First Installment | $20,000 |
| Tax Rate on the Payouts | 15.5% |
| Break-Even Tax Rate on the Payouts | 38.1% |
| Exempt From Your Former Work State’s Tax | Not Exempt |
| Possible Maryland Tax on the Payouts | $4,750 |
| Social Security and Medicare Due This Year | $2,350 |
| Amount the Company Owes You When Payouts Start | $100,000 |
| Years Until the Last Payment | 14 years |
| 20% Additional Tax If the Plan Failed This Year | $20,000 |
The calculator summarizes it this way: “At your inputs, deferring $100,000 comes out +$17,840 to +$22,590 after tax compared with taking it now, paid as 5 yearly payments, 2036 to 2040: the low end if Maryland taxes the payouts, before any credit from Florida, which is Unknown here; the high end if it does not.” Its payout schedule shows five $20,000 payments, each with $3,100 of tax, leaving $16,900 a year. Its side-by-side table shows the same deferral paid as a lump sum leaving $79,300 (+$12,386 to +$17,390), and paid over 10 yearly payments leaving $88,000 (+$26,090), a form exempt from Maryland tax after a move. Results for your own inputs will differ.
Reviewed by Jeff Judge, CFP®, AEP®, ChFC®, CLU®, Managing Partner, Chesapeake Financial Planners. Last updated November 2, 2026. Tax year 2026.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does deferring compensation save Social Security and Medicare tax?
Usually not. Under the special timing rule, deferred pay counts as wages for Social Security and Medicare when it is earned and vested, not when it is paid. In the example, $2,350 is still due this year. The payouts and the earnings on them are not taxed for Social Security and Medicare again.
What is the break-even tax rate?
It is the tax rate on the payouts at which deferring and taking the pay now come out the same. In the example, the payouts are taxed at about 15.5%, well below the 38.1% break-even rate, so deferring comes out ahead at these inputs. If your payout-year income and state were the same as today’s, the advantage would shrink to about $5,140.
Can my current state tax my deferred compensation after I move?
It can, unless federal law exempts the payout form. 4 U.S.C. 114 stops a former work state from taxing payments for life, yearly payments over 10 or more years, and payments from a plan kept only to pay benefits above the qualified plan limits. In the example, 5 yearly payments are not exempt, so Maryland might tax them (about $4,750), while 10 yearly payments would be exempt.
What happens if my employer goes bankrupt?
Money in a nonqualified plan is generally an unsecured promise. Even money set aside in a rabbi trust stays available to the company’s general creditors. The calculator shows how much the company would owe you when payouts start and how many years until the last payment, so you can see the exposure. It does not rate any company.
Can I change my payout election later?
Under Section 409A, a change cannot take effect for 12 months, must push the payment at least 5 years later, and, for a payment due on a fixed date, must be made at least 12 months before that date. Enter your scheduled payment date and the date you would make the change, and the calculator shows the last day to change it and the earliest new date. Your plan document controls what is allowed.
Related planning services: Stock Options, Buyout and Severance, Financial Planning for Tech and SaaS Professionals, Retirement Readiness, Financial Planning for Retirees and Pre-Retirees.
Related calculators: 403(b) and 457(b) Contribution Calculator, Roth Conversion Calculator and Financial Independence Target Estimator.
See all financial planning calculators
Want to talk through your own numbers with an adviser?
Important disclosures
This calculator is for educational purposes only. It provides a simplified, hypothetical estimate based on the information you enter and on 2026 federal and state tax rules, applied the same way in the payout years. Any growth is a rate you choose, not a forecast. Payout elections are set by your plan document and Section 409A, and state rules on deferred pay vary. Deferred compensation is generally an unsecured promise of your employer. It does not consider all factors that may affect your situation, such as your plan’s own rules, employer credits, or estate tax. It is not tax, legal, investment, or financial planning advice. Consult a qualified tax professional about your specific circumstances. Tax laws change, and results are not guaranteed.
The opinions voiced in this material are for general information only and are not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual. This information is not intended to be a substitute for specific individualized tax, investment or legal advice. We suggest that you discuss your specific situation with a qualified tax, legal or financial advisor. All investing involves risk including loss of principal. No strategy assures success or protects against loss. There is no guarantee that a diversified portfolio will enhance overall returns or outperform a non-diversified portfolio. DiversificationSpreading investments across multiple asset classes, sectors, and geographies so a loss in one area doesn’t devastate your entire portfolio. It’s the financial equivalent of not putting all your eggs in one basket — and it’s one of the few strategies that can reduce risk without necessarily reducing expected returns. does not protect against market risk.
Advisors associated with Chesapeake Financial Planners may be either (1) LPL Financial Registered Representatives offering securities through LPL Financial, Member FINRA and SIPC, and investment advisor representatives offering investment advice through Great Valley Advisor Group; or (2) solely investment advisor representatives offering investment advice through Great Valley Advisor Group and not affiliated with LPL Financial. Great Valley Advisor Group and Chesapeake Financial Planners are separate entities from LPL Financial.
