Skip to content

Think a Roth Conversion Is Always Smart? Here Are 5 Times It Could Cost You

| Last reviewed:

KiplingerOriginally published in Kiplinger

I wrote this Adviser Intel piece for Kiplinger because somewhere along the way "conversions can be smart" curdled into "conversions are always smart," and that is where I start to worry. A Roth conversion is a tool, not a virtue.

The logic of a conversion rests on paying tax now, at today's rate, to avoid tax later. That only works when today's rate is lower than the rate you expect down the road. I laid out five situations where a conversion usually doesn't make sense.

One, you are in a high-income year, when a conversion stacks on top of a bracket already near its peak. Two, you would have to use the IRA itself to pay the tax, which shrinks the amount reaching the Roth and can trigger a penalty if you are under 59½. Three, you expect your tax rate to fall in retirement, which means converting now pays a higher rate to avoid a lower one. Four, the money will pass to heirs who get a step-up in basis on other assets anyway, which can change the estate math. Five, state taxes erase the federal benefit, for example if you plan to retire to a low-tax state.

The pattern is that a conversion is good or bad relative to your bracket today versus later, whether you have outside cash to pay the tax, your estate plans and your state. I am not arguing against conversions. I am arguing against treating them as automatic. Sometimes the most valuable thing a conversion analysis produces is the decision to wait.

Read the full article at Kiplinger →

Related services: retirement income planning for retirees and pre-retirees · a retirement readiness assessment

Related article on our site: Should I Do Roth Conversions Before I Retire?

About Jeff Judge, CFP®: meet Jeff and the Chesapeake Financial Planners team.


Disclosures

The information provided is for educational purposes only and should not be construed as investment advice. Investment strategies should be tailored to individual circumstances, risk tolerance, and goals. Past performance doesn't guarantee future results. Consult with qualified financial professionals regarding your specific situation.

© 2026 Chesapeake Financial Planners | Not to be reproduced in whole or in part. All rights reserved.

Jeff Judge, CFP®
Jeff Judge Managing Partner
Jeff is one of Chesapeake’s founding partners and a go-to advisor for professionals navigating complex transitions like retirement, business sales, or sudden windfalls. With nearly two decades of experience, he’s known for delivering calm, clear guidance when it matters most. Clients say working with him feels like talking to a longtime friend, if that friend happened to be a financial expert.
Share:

Ready to stop second-guessing and start feeling in control?

Book a 30-60 minute “Fit Call” to see if we’re the right partner for your financial life. No pressure, no jargon, just a conversation focused on your goals and whether our approach makes sense for your needs.

See if you’re a fit
See if you’re a fit